As the New York Yankees prepare for their postseason run this weekend against the winner of the Baltimore Orioles vs. Kansas City Royals series, they are facing a challenge at first base. Anthony Rizzo fractured two fingers in a recent game against the Pittsburgh Pirates, leaving the team to consider alternatives.
In response, the Yankees have called up Ben Rice and are also looking at Oswaldo Cabrera as potential options for first base. Another possibility is DJ LeMahieu, who is currently rehabbing from a right hip impingement and is uncertain about his availability for the ALDS.
However, the Yankees might be better off without LeMahieu in the lineup, especially when examining his recent performance statistics. Among players with at least 200 plate appearances this season, LeMahieu recorded one of the lowest OPS figures at .527, ranking him eighth-worst among 365 players.
At 36 years old and having dealt with multiple injuries in recent seasons, LeMahieu’s effectiveness has diminished. While he doesn’t struggle with strikeouts, his contact is often weak and predominantly ground balls, failing to create the impact needed in a playoff setting.
Bringing LeMahieu back without competitive game experience could pose a significant risk. He would likely face tough pitchers like Cole Ragans or Corbin Burnes, which could expose his current limitations further.
Despite Rizzo’s hopes of returning later in the postseason, the Yankees should consider sticking with Cabrera or Rice. Neither player is expected to be a game-changer, but both could prove to be more reliable options than a veteran coming off an injury.
Fans seem to share the sentiment that LeMahieu should not be on the postseason roster. Most appreciate his contributions over the years, particularly during his standout seasons in 2019-20, but performance-wise, he doesn’t warrant a spot this time.
Ultimately, the Yankees need to prioritize winning over loyalty to past players. If they want a shot at the World Series, they should be willing to move on from LeMahieu and focus on players who can contribute effectively. The postseason is no time for sentimentality, and tough decisions will be crucial for success.