The WNBA’s 2024 season has been marked by heightened attention and intensity, particularly due to the rivalry between rookies Caitlin Clark and Angel Reese. This burgeoning rivalry has not only captivated fans but also stirred significant controversy, with some of the discourse veering into racist, sexist, and homophobic territory. In light of these issues, WNBA Commissioner Cathy Engelbert’s recent comments on CNBC’s Power Lunch have drawn considerable criticism.
When asked about the surge in negative and harmful rhetoric associated with the Clark-Reese rivalry, Engelbert’s response focused less on addressing the problematic behavior and more on the league’s growing cultural significance and business opportunities. Engelbert compared the current rivalry to the historic Bird-Magic rivalry of 1979, suggesting that such rivalries are integral to generating interest and viewership in sports. She stated, “There’s no more apathy. Everybody cares. It is a little bit of that Bird-Magic moment if you recall, from 1979. And so we have that moment with these two.”
While Engelbert acknowledged the importance of rivalries in driving fan engagement, her comments have been widely criticized for seeming to downplay or ignore the serious issues of racism and sexism that have emerged. Critics argue that her focus on marketing and rivalry overshadows the need for addressing the real harm and toxicity directed at players.
Many fans and players have expressed their discontent with Engelbert’s response. The backlash has been vocal, with calls for her resignation gaining momentum. Comments on social media reflect a deep frustration with Engelbert’s handling of the situation. Some users have questioned her competence and commitment to player welfare, with one critic stating, “Serious question: How is Cathy Engelbert able to keep her job? What has she done to elevate the WNBA? They asked her about racism and sexism. She responded with verbal garbage that highlighted rivalry and endorsements. She needs to go ASAP and is a part of the problem.”
Others have accused Engelbert and the league of failing to protect their players and address the underlying issues contributing to the negative fan behavior. “Like many of us have been saying, the @WNBA is complicit in pushing the rhetoric this season without regard for the players, their safety, or their mental health. The players are people, not just a product. Shame on Cathy Engelbert and everyone involved,” another critic wrote.
Engelbert, who has been the WNBA commissioner since 2019, has overseen significant growth in the league’s visibility and commercial success. However, her recent handling of this sensitive issue has raised questions about her priorities and approach to player safety and inclusion. The ongoing criticism suggests a need for a more nuanced and proactive strategy to address and combat racism and sexism within the league’s fanbase and broader community.
As the season progresses, the response to Engelbert’s remarks will likely continue to influence the public discourse around the WNBA’s handling of such critical issues. The league’s ability to navigate these challenges while maintaining its growth trajectory will be closely scrutinized by fans, players, and stakeholders alike.