The New York Mets are facing a critical decision in their quest to retain fan-favorite Pete Alonso, the team’s powerhouse first baseman. Known as the “Polar Bear,” Alonso has been a major contributor to the Mets’ offensive success, but the team finds itself in a tricky position as it tries to balance keeping its star player without overcommitting in a market that’s becoming increasingly difficult to navigate. While the Mets have the financial capability to retain Alonso, they are looking to make moves to ensure they can keep him without overpaying, potentially using the trade market to free up funds.
One of the primary options for the Mets in this situation could involve trading outfielder Starling Marte. The 36-year-old Marte is still a capable player but has become expendable due to the Mets’ crowded outfield. With new acquisitions like Juan Soto and Jose Siri, plus the return of Jesse Winker, the Mets’ outfield now features a logjam that could make Marte’s departure a logical next step. Additionally, the presence of established players like Brandon Nimmo and Tyrone Taylor further complicates Marte’s role in the lineup.
While the Mets would likely receive interest in Marte, his contract and recent performance decline could make the trade process more challenging. Marte is owed $19.5 million for 2024, with that number set to rise to $20.75 million in 2025, which could be a tough pill for potential suitors to swallow. His age and injury history also lower his trade value, and although Marte posted a better offensive output in 2024, his wRC+ dropped to 75 in 2023, a clear sign of his regression compared to his prime years.
Despite his decline, Marte still offers value, particularly as a depth piece for a team looking to make a playoff push. However, the Mets may have to absorb part of his salary or attach a prospect to the deal in order to generate more interest and make the trade more palatable for teams. Such a move could help free up valuable financial space, allowing the Mets to prioritize Alonso’s future in New York.
For the Mets, trading Marte would be a difficult decision given his history with the team, but it’s a move that may be necessary if they want to keep Alonso on the roster. The team faces a delicate balancing act, as they must ensure they don’t sacrifice long-term success in favor of short-term nostalgia. As much as fans love Alonso, the Mets need to maintain a well-constructed roster, and making tough decisions like trading Marte might be a key to securing their star first baseman’s future.