There’s speculation about whether the New York Giants expressed interest in trading for former first-overall pick Bryce Young from the Carolina Panthers. However, it seems unlikely that Young would be the solution for the Giants, who are grappling with deeper issues than can be resolved by a single young quarterback.
Currently, the Giants are struggling to stay afloat, and general manager Joe Schoen along with head coach Brian Daboll are under significant pressure to produce wins. If they fail to turn the situation around soon, their jobs could be in jeopardy.
In this challenging environment, acquiring a developing quarterback like Young wouldn’t provide an instant fix for the franchise’s woes.
A recent report from Adam Schefter suggested that several teams had “expressed interest” in trading for Young, although it remains unclear whether the Giants were among them. The speculation surrounding the Giants is hard to overlook.
Young undeniably possesses talent, having garnered praise for his vision and arm strength during his time at Alabama. However, his confidence has suffered under the Panthers’ outdated offensive system, which does not play to his strengths. Given that the Giants are already facing offensive struggles, bringing in Young might complicate matters further rather than offering a straightforward solution.
What the Giants truly need is a fresh start rather than taking on more risk. Acquiring Young would mean taking on the remainder of his contract, which includes a $10.3 million cap hit in 2025 and $12 million in 2026. Additionally, if the Giants part ways with Daniel Jones after this season, they would still incur $22.2 million in dead money. This could lead to the team spending around $33 million on two quarterbacks who may not be capable of turning the franchise around.
While Young’s potential remains, the Giants would be better off avoiding a quarterback who may come with bad habits and questionable decision-making at this pivotal moment in their development. Instead, they should focus on drafting a fresh talent and starting anew.
The Panthers, for their part, have shown no inclination to trade Young. With the possibility of drafting another quarterback, retaining Young to see if he can improve seems like the prudent choice for Carolina.
As for the Giants, their attention should shift to the future. They are likely to pursue a quarterback in the upcoming draft, with prospects like Carson Beck from Georgia and Cam Ward from Miami potentially in the mix to lead the franchise moving forward.
In conclusion, while Bryce Young is a talented player, the Giants would benefit more from looking ahead and investing in new talent rather than trying to salvage a struggling player. Building from the ground up appears to be the most sensible strategy for the team at this juncture.